Opinion analysis: Court rejects gender-based distinctions in citizenship laws

Mark Wilson  Getty Images

WASHINGTON — A unanimous Supreme Court on Monday struck down part of an unusual immigration law that treats fathers and mothers differently when it comes to conferring citizenship on children born outside the U.S. Writing for six of the eight participating justices, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said the differing requirements were "stunningly anachronistic".

The case at the court involved Luis Ramon Morales-Santana, who was brought to Puerto Rico at the age of 13 after being born in the Dominican Republic to an unwed US citizen father and a Dominican mother (they later married). In the meantime, the five-year requirement "should apply, prospectively, to children born to unwed US -citizen mothers".

Popular Video This young teenage singer was shocked when Keith Urban invited her on stage at his concert.

The board said Morales‐Santana's father had not satisfied the physical residency requirements for unwed fathers since he left the US when he was 18 years old, 20 days shy of his 19th birthday and fifth year of residence in the U.S.

Essentially, the court's ruling requires Congress to consider men and women, mothers and fathers, as equals in the transference of citizenship, according to the ACLU's Sandra Park, senior staff attorney for the civil liberties organizations' Women's Rights Project. "Concern about the attachment of foreign-born children to the United States explains the treatment of unwed citizen fathers, who, according to the familiar stereotype, would care little about, and have scant contact with, their nonmarital children". His father failed to meet the law's five-year requirements by 20 days. His mother was a citizen of the Dominican Republic and his father was a USA citizen who had not spent more than five years in the United States after his 14th birthday.

The citizenship issue became a crucial one when the federal government initiated proceedings to deport Morales-Santana after a series of criminal convictions, and Morales-Santana countered that he was a USA citizen because his father had been one. After oral argument, the justices were deadlocked 4-4, which left the lower court's ruling in the government's favor in place.


A federal appeals court struck down the law and said the shorter one-year period must apply to both unwed fathers and mothers. In 2010, the court agreed to hear another case that presented the same issue, but Justice Elena Kagan was recused from that case, presumably because she had been the US solicitor general when the federal government filed its brief opposing review.

The case is one of several with immigration-related themes that are before the justices at a time when President Donald Trump's administration is pursuing efforts to strengthen immigration enforcement.

In the interim, she said, the government must ensure the laws are administered in a way that is free from gender-based discrimination.

When Chief Justice John Roberts announced this morning that Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was the author of the opinion, it was a good sign for Morales-Santana. The Justice Department said Congress wanted to make sure there is a strong connection between a child born overseas and the United States before granting citizenship.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr. did not join Ginsburg's reasoning, and agreed only in overturning the 2nd Circuit's relief to Morales-Santana.

Related News:

  • Harry Kane Wants Permanent England Captaincy

    Harry Kane Wants Permanent England Captaincy

    England have now gone 35 games and nearly eight years since they last lost a World Cup or European Championship qualifying match. However, Kane slammed in at the far post deep into stoppage time to break the hearts of the Tartan Army.
    Injured Sharapova pulls out of Wimbledon, grass circuit

    Injured Sharapova pulls out of Wimbledon, grass circuit

    To read this article in one of Houston's most-spoken languages, click on the button below. Two years before that, at 17, Sharapova won her first major title at Wimbledon.
    Royals' Moustakas homers to halt Astros' win streak at 11

    Royals' Moustakas homers to halt Astros' win streak at 11

    Royals relievers Kevin McCarthy , Travis Wood and Minor worked 5 1/3 scoreless innings after rookie Jakob Junis was pulled. The Royals trailed 7-1 entering the bottom of the fourth. "I was thinking I might have to slide headfirst", Gordons said.
  • Result, not performance, counted against Crusaders - Gatland

    Result, not performance, counted against Crusaders - Gatland

    The Crusaders scrum - They looked strong, at one point motoring the Lions back , but fell foul of referee Mathieu Raynal. Stuart Hogg and Jonathan Davies face a race against time to be ready to take on the Maori All Blacks on Saturday.
    Even moderate alcohol consumption is bad for your brain

    Even moderate alcohol consumption is bad for your brain

    Even drinking a moderate amount of alcohol can cause brain damage over a prolonged period of time, scientists have said. Other scientists expressed scepticism about some of the methodology, and the self-reporting of alcohol consumption.
    Global airlines group advocates against laptop ban on flights

    Global airlines group advocates against laptop ban on flights

    Meanwhile, it said Latin America and Middle East carriers are expected to earn US$800 million and US$400 million respectively. It said about half the industry profits are being generated in North America (US$15.4 billion).
  • Middlesbrough appoint former Leeds boss Garry Monk

    Middlesbrough appoint former Leeds boss Garry Monk

    GARRY MONK has made keeping Ben Gibson his priority after starting work as Middlesbrough boss. "This club ticks all the right boxes for me".
    Square Enix Reveals Life Is Strange: Before The Storm At E3

    Square Enix Reveals Life Is Strange: Before The Storm At E3

    This prequel is set three years before the original game and expands on the period when Max left Chloe. In Life Is Strange , Chloe has been changing her life around after experiencing tragedies in her life.

    Comey's a political 'showboat': Pro-Trump group

    Hale said in a statement: "Director Coats does not discuss his private conversations with the President". Days after Comey's firing, the Justice Department appointed Mueller to oversee the federal investigation.
  • Bill Cosby's defense rests without hearing from famed comedian

    Steele meticulously itemized evidence, arguing that it supported the state's assertion that Cosby "drugged" Constand. She testified that Cosby gave her three small, blue pills that she thought were herbal supplements.
    Petition grows against May's deal with ultra-conservatives

    Petition grows against May's deal with ultra-conservatives

    The DUP has close ties with the Conservatives , and it is in favor of the U.K.'s withdrawal from the European Union. May said Barwell would help her "reflect on the election and why it did not deliver the result I hoped for".
    U.S.  national security personnel charged with leaking secret Russian document

    U.S. national security personnel charged with leaking secret Russian document

    Victor is the first person accused of leaking classified information to be charged with a crime under the Trump administration. Snowden criticized Winner's arrest in a statement he released Tuesday through the Freedom of the Press Foundation.


Most liked

'Wonder Woman' buries 'The Mummy' at box office
The movie did well at overseas box-office, earning over 141.8 million United States dollars from 63 markets. The Mummy fared better overseas, however, where the film was No. 1 with $141.8 million from 63 territories.

Xbox to unveil 'most powerful' console
The Xbox E3 2017 briefing is expected to bring news on Project Scorpio , including its official name, price, and release date. It's not clear, however, whether the Xbox One S price drop is meant to be temporary or permanent.

Jennifer Lawrence OK after both engines failed on private plane, rep says
Ganyard added that without all of the details, it's hard to determine how serious the incident was. He explained that airplanes have two engines because the other would be a backup in case one fails.

Apple Introduces 'Do Not Disturb While Driving' Feature for iOS 11
For the first time in years, Apple Inc . will use its annual developer conference to tout not just its software, but hardware too. With Apple iOS 11 , one can now 3D Touch a word to LookUp to search the dictionary or get suggestions from iTunes or App Store .

James Comey's Senate Intelligence Committee testimony
He also claimed that Russian Federation was involved in the election of President Trump during the election. One of Trump Jr.'s biggest gripes was when Comey leaked his own private memos to the press.

European Central Bank keeps stimulus in place
While few expect that to happen, the words underline that the bank is not yet willing to call time on the stimulus program. The 60 billion euros ($67 billion) per month in bond purchases are to run at least through the end of the year.

Cleveland fires 1 officer, suspends 2nd in Rice shooting
The killing became part of a national outcry about police violence against minorities, particularly black boys and men. The move comes two and a half years after he fatally shot Rice, reportedly mistaking Rice's pellet gun for a real one.

Lions beaten 22-16 by Blues in Auckland in 2nd tour match
They struggled again in a game played at pace and were unable to dictate the pace of the game through their control of possession. Perofeta was handed his first start for the Blues but apart from the pass to Ioane, he struggled to control the match.

Liverpool end interest in Van Dijk after Southampton row
Van Dijk signed for Southampton from Celtic in 2015 and has since made 55 Premier League starts, scoring four goals. Another report from the Guardian claims that Klopp is also keen on signing AS Roma's Mohamed Salah.

PlayStation Plus Free Games For June 2017 Revealed Again
Assuming your console hasn't already downloaded update 4.70, you may want to hold off until Sony publicly addresses this issue. According to Redmond Pie , Sony yesterday pushed out a new update to the software which powers its PlayStation 4 console.

Justin Trudeau and Barack Obama Hug After Dinner at Montreal Restaurant
The landmark agreement, considered a hallmark of Obama's efforts to combat climate change, was panned by many on the right. Due to Trump, the U.S.is one of just three countries, other than Nicaragua and Syria, to not participate in the deal.

London attacker stopped en route to Syria, flagged as suspect
The threat level remains at moderate but frontline Gardaí have warned they've had no counter-terrorism training. Commuters walk across London Bridge , with new security barriers, after work in London , Tuesday, June 6, 2017.

Senate Republicans claim progress on health care legislation
Trump said Tuesday that the tax cut would be "the biggest in our country's history if we pass it the way we'd like it passed". The crux of the legislative stalemate is the inability of Republicans to deliver on their health care promise.

Real Madrid celebrates 12th European Cup with fans in Spain
We won La Liga and the Champions League and that's very hard . "This season was wonderful again, last season was incredible ". Juventus became the first club in the history of the competition to break the €100m barrier for revenue.

Oklahoma defends softball title with 5-4 win over Florida
She's won back-to-back title for the first time in her illustrious career and given the Sooners early dibs on Team of the Decade. It stood in against a historic pitching staff and, with Knigten's swings the lasting images, came out with the trophy.